Without taurine, heart failure is a major risk. Winner: IAMS. The former is very good quality meat, and the other is a rich source of glucosamine and chondroitin. = 3/4-1 cup22lbs. The latter is also suitable for weight control due to its natural fiber content. Purina Beyond formulas are made for adult dogs from quality ingredients. The primary ingredient and the main source of protein is chicken. Fiber is important for proper digestion, but 4% is also great. When you factor that into the price difference, youll see that the IAMS wet cat food is more expensive than similar products. When a threat is detected or seen, brand products is recalled to ensure product safety. This means fewer carbohydrates and fats, and fats are good if they contain omega fatty acids. Of these, corn is quite questionable as it causes sensitivity in many dogs. It is a very good quality tasty and easily digestible meat. This food is affordably priced but still packed with the nutrients your cat needs. Each recipe has low dietary magnesium and has been designed to reduce urinary pH. 1%, Moisture max. A bonus is that Hills has sustainability in mind by becoming Total Resource Use and Efficiency (TRUE) Certified. Incidentally, various joint diseases are common in these dogs anyway, which can be greatly supported by glucosamine and chondroitin. The founders original goal was to create a farm animal food company, but later this brand became one of the best-known pet food brands in the industry. As a pet owner, youve certainly heard of Purina and IAMS. 15%, Crude Fiber max. If you would like to change your settings or withdraw consent at any time, the link to do so is in our privacy policy accessible from our home page.. Developed in 1986, the purina one food brand was created to be purinas premium product line. . Helps Maintain Urinary Tract Health by Reducing Urinary pH and Providing Low Dietary Magnesium. And dont worry, fat does not clog animal hearts as it does human hearts. It also has vitamin E to keep your cats immune system in top condition and omega-6 fatty acid to keep its coat and skin looking and feeling healthier than ever. Corn, rice, barley, and wheat have all been associated with allergies and digestive problems. The only benefit of the IAMS product is the L-carnitine content. Their costs are nearly the same, and neither brand has an alarming rate of recall. Arginine is vital in helping filter ammonia from the bloodstream. IAMS is an international company thats sold in more than 75 countries. Top ingredients include pork liver, carrots, chicken, tuna, rice, spinach, chicken fat and fish oil as a source of omega-3 fatty acids. our process. Purina Pro Plan Veterinary Diet UR St/Ox Urinary Cat Food; 11. These important nutrients support your puppys immune system. Nick Blackmer began his information-digging career as a library reference assistant, then worked for more than 20 years as a researcher and fact checker in print publishing before moving into digital publishing. In the wild, a cat would eat a range of textures and get much of their necessary water through eating fresh meat. While there are some questionable ingredients in these recipes, customer reviews are excellent. One problem with many dry cat foods is that they tend to lack protein. We and our partners use cookies to Store and/or access information on a device. This causes severe joint problems. Bag. The IAMS recipe contains more omega fatty acids due to fish oil. Learn how to create a happy, healthy home for your pet. Linoleic acid is an omega-6 fatty acid, to nourish skin and coat. The Purina ONE True Instinct High Protein Natural Wet Cat Food is advertised as having zero fillers, which is something that all pet parents would appreciate. Heres the deal: your pet requires it in the proper proportions. Their habits may give you clues to their texture preferences. Chicken is the #1 ingredient in this protein-rich cat kibble formula. The amounts of nutrients needed vary in each stage of lifefrom kitten to adolescent, during pregnancy and nursing, and as a senior cat. Two of her cats lived happily and healthily into their early 20s. I also have some articles comparing Purina to other brands. check out our list of best low protein cat food. However, that purchase wasnt complete since the European branch of IAMS was sold to Spectrum Brands, being purchased again in 2020 by United Petfood. . But the IAMS High Protein dry cat food contains a minimum of 32% crude protein. Related Read:Purina Cat Chow Naturals Cat Food Review 2021: Recalls, Pros & Cons. Offers Balanced Nutrition to Help Support a Healthy Immune System. For wet dog foods, Iams typically provides a little more fat (about 3.32% more). Think about the type and quality of the ingredients, including if they're organic, local, or if they have other certifications. The primary aim of this article is to provide a structured comparison of two renowned brands, Iams and Purina One. Formulated with nutritionists and experts, they ingredients are simple, recognizable and formulated in compliance with AAFCO standards for all life stages. Two portions are just 2.6 ounces, compared to the 3-ounce servings from many other brands. Any food with naturals in the name tends to cost an arm and a leg, but the Purina Cat Chow Naturals is a different story. Since Purina has a staggering selection of cat and dog food formulations ranging from budget options to premium choices, I will compare IAMS to the Purina ONE product line to ensure they fall under the same price points. Blue Buffalo W+U Weight Management and Urinary Care canned wet food is an excellent choice carried by many veterinarians. Cat Food Selector; Cat Articles; Check Your C.A.T.S. This is because large breed puppies are prone to overgrowth. However, caution should be exercised with caloric intake in these dogs. Softens and breaks down pure struvite stonesHelps prevent calcium oxalate stones. There are real customer reviews for both brands that praise the excellent taste of the products. Purina brought a lot to the table as well, with a more versatile selection of products that include some specialty foods that bring about specific results like reducing the allergens your cat is releasing or achieving and maintaining urinary tract health. Can Adult Cats Eat Kitten Food? John Joseph is a nutritionist, Cat lover who is passionate about helping fellow Cat lovers to learn about feline nutrition. They create high-quality food products that are made from natural, nutritious ingredients. Ground Whole Grain Barley, lamb meal, cornmeal, Brewers Rice, Fish Meal (Omega 3, Omega 6), Ground Whole Grain Sorghum, Salt, Potassium Chloride, Dried Beet Pulp. Support it, with the high-quality, specialized nutrition of Purina Pro Plan. I did not find any information on Purina about how much of this important fatty acid it contains. Of course, this formula also contains added vitamins and minerals, so your dogs immune system will also function properly. Luckily, once Mars inc. purchased IAMS, the quality improved, though its still conveniently available at big-box chains. What makes this food special is how it reduces the allergens your cat gives off, reducing the likelihood of allergic reactions to your cat. As in human food ingredient labels, ingredients are listed in order from most to least based on weight and include the percentages of protein, fat, fiber, and moisture. Purina One dog food is also of outstanding quality. Fats improve the taste/texture of food. Premium wet cat recipes such as Wellness Natural Cat Wet Foods are a great place to start when it comes to boosting hydration, and these diets are available from most pet retailers., Prescription diets are therapeutic nutritional recipes that support an acute or chronic medical condition, adds Dr. Bernal. Hes worked on content spanning the human life cycle, from pregnancy to palliative care and many points in between. In 1950, their first product was introduced, IAMS 999. Plus, it includes vitamin E to maintain a healthy feline immune system, as well as essential nutrients, like calcium and potassium, for a healthy heart. However, there is no doubt that this company played a significant role in making it possible to find dog food everywhere for different dietary needs today. Lorraine Wilde, M.S. Key Benefits: Specially formulated for adult cats with urinary health problems. However, the information found on Excited Cats should not be viewed as veterinary advice. They would consume prey that contains high amounts of protein, moderate amounts of fat, and a nominal amount of carbohydrates. By law, the USDA must apply the same standard to cat food that they apply to human food. IAMS developed its formula specifically for puppies in the 80s. Urinary Tract Health: Me-O Dry Adult Cat Food: . For the purposes of this comparison, all percentages are computed on a dry matter basis. However, the crude fat content is still 9%, which is ideal for overweight dogs. Its not very beneficial for dogs, so only choose these products if youre on a really tight budget. One of the most critical parts of this is to contrast different products with each other. As you can see, IAMS has had a lot more recalls over the years. This includes Purinas premium products. How much of it is real, and how much is advertising? Purina One has a greater number of recipes than Iams, however, Iams has more variety. However, Purina uses more real meat in the recipes, so it wins in terms of taste. The basic ingredients are very similar to the puppy formula. Below, I have collected and reviewed similar products from the two brands. These recipes include quite a few meat by-products as well as wheat, corn, and soy. This can be managed by providing the cat with low-protein veteraniry diets that are exclusively made to match the need of cats with kidney or liver problems. The joints of these canines are vulnerable. To avoid factoring in the moisture content that is inclusive when weighing per pound, the recommended metric will be to budget in kcal. It is easily digestible and contains a lot of fiber and other useful nutrients. The first carbohydrate source is rice, a wholesome grain, well digestible and contains many useful nutrients. Cat Food Young Again 50/22 Purina Pro Plan Urinary Tract Health Formula Iams Veterinary Formula Urinary-S Low pH/S Formula Urinary-O Moderate pH/O Hills Prescrip-tion Diet c/d Multicare Feline Bladder Health Hills Prescrip-tion Diet c/d Multicare Feline Bladder Health with Chicken 1st ingredient Chicken Meal Chicken Meal Corn Gluten Meal It follows that the number of Purina products is also higher. Calcium, phosphorus and other nutrients for strong bones and healthy joints. In general, look for food that has high moisture and low magnesium content. While a lot has changed for the company in that time, one thing remains the same; their push for purity in pet food. Because of this, if your pet is overweight, you should look for a healthy weight or weight management formula. With just 0.9% carbohydrates, you dont have to worry about feeding your cat anything that doesnt sit well with them. The ingredients are recognizable on the label and in the food. We looked at both brands, taking a deep dive into their histories and manufacturing practices, and the more we dug . 6. However, Purina is also available in supermarkets and grocery stores. It contains both chicken fat and fish oil. We have partnered with Chewy.com to offer the best deal on wide array of high quality cat food products to our visitors. Non-synthetic preservatives include vitamin C (ascorbic acid) or vitamin E (tocopheryl acetate or tocopherol acetate). Similarly, IAMS seems to use more animal-based ingredients than Purina does. But the IAMS High Protein dry cat food contains a minimum of 32% crude protein. Brands are rated on value, quality of ingredients and how much the cat liked the food, as well as overall satisfaction and likelihood of recommending. Its true that our furry friends may look the other way at mealtime if they didnt like the food. This is my detailed comparison of Purina vs Iams dog food brands in 2022. Formulated to reduce urinary pH and promote the health of the urinary system for a happy and healthy cat. Her work has included Run Those Dogs, Parents Magazine, Leaders in Heels, Sheownsit.com, and Miss Millennia Magazine, among other publications and, most recently, a Sniffspot host. Iams Proactive Health Urinary Tract Dry Cat Food; 6. But there were some incidences where the Purina foods were more cost-effective. Domesticated cats that arent eating a natural diet of rodents and other critters arent exposed to bacteria they would encounter in the wild. Thats not the case for many foods that are cheaper. 4.6. Alltech Acid Balance lowers urinary pH to prevent bladder stones and struvite crystals. For example, the IAMS wet cat foods are a bit expensive for what you get, especially compared to Purina. We and our partners use data for Personalised ads and content, ad and content measurement, audience insights and product development. But today, youll find IAMS in many major retailers, including grocery chains and big-box stores. There is a relatively insignificant difference between the crude fiber content of the two brands. Unfortunately, the result was reduced quality and a class-action lawsuit. The other carbohydrate sources are not very good quality. Below, I will try to compare the two brands from different perspectives. Read our, Evanger's EVx Restricted: Urinary Tract at Evangersdogfood.com, Hill's Prescription Diet Multicare Urinary Care Cat Food at Amazon, IAMS Adult Urinary Tract Health Dry Cat Food at Amazon, Blue Buffalo Weight Management + Urinary Care Wet Food at Amazon, Purina Pro Plan Urinary Tract Health Canned Cat Food at Amazon, Under the Weather Urinary Support Soft Chews for Cats at Amazon, Hill's Prescription Diet c/d Multicare Urinary Care with Chicken Canned Cat Food, IAMS PROACTIVE HEALTH Adult Urinary Tract Health Dry Cat Food with Chicken, Blue Buffalo W+U Weight Management + Urinary Care Wet Food, Purina Pro Plan Urinary Tract Health Canned Cat Food, The 7 Best Cat Water Fountains of 2023, Tested and Reviewed, Under the Weather Urinary Support Soft Chews for Cats, What to Consider in a Cat Food for Urinary Tract Health. On average, Purina Pro Plan guarantees about 8.46% more protein than Iams. Just for the sake of example: I cant compare the IAMS puppy formula to a Purina senior formula. If your first choice doesnt fit, transition slowly to another. Some may prefer a soft minced food or chunky bites. Both wet and dry food can be found among these products. It works as a prebiotic in your cats digestive system which can promote a healthy microbiome in your cats stomach and intestine which is very valuable in enhancing healthy digestion and nutrient absorption. In all other cases, I recommend Purina, as the Premium formulas of this brand are unbeatable in this competition. For working dogs and sports dogs, so-called Performance-oriented diets are also available on this line. This post contains affiliate links, and I may earn a commission if you buy something through these links. To get such a high amount of protein in this food, multiple sources of animal protein were used, which will provide your cat with a diverse amino acid profile. Finding the best diet for your dog is not easy. 7. The price of the two products is almost the same, Purina is a bit more economical. These two minerals are essential for the health of the joints of old dogs. These are intended to alleviate the complaints of dogs with various chronic diseases. . Manage Settings The main protein sources are the same for both. Since those early beginnings, IAMS has gone through several major transformations. 11% may not seem high, but remember, 80% of this food is just water. Its no coincidence that Im listing this product line first. Do they lick their food? The two products are very similar in many ways, so it's not easy to announce a winner. Shop and buy the best ca food from IAMS. . Compare the best cat food using expert ratings and consumer reviews in the official ConsumerAffairs buyers guide. Take your time deciding if its the right fit. The ingredients are exclusively natural, such as meats, fish, vegetables, wholesome grains, etc. Although it is not such a good quality protein source, it contains many glucosamine and chondroitin. Her current feline companions have been challenged by digestive and urinary tract health issues. Here are some of the cat foods in the market that are just as good as Hill's Prescription Diet c/d Multicare Feline Stress. One of the main staples in the Purina lineup is Purina ONE. Nutritional and flavor diversity for your cat, Meat by-products are the first ingredient. Look for foods that list a high protein content of a specific meat first and if any grains are included, whole grains are best because of the nutrients they contain. We do our best to help you better understand your cats, but the information on this blog is not a substitute for veterinary guidance. 8.5%, Fat min. Later, of course, other companies began to follow this line. While both companies use quality ingredients as well as fillers, we feel that IAMS tends to use better ingredients overall. Theyre added to make your pet feel full with fewer high quality ingredients by weight. Taking a look at the nutritional label, we can see that this food is packed with protein. And how much is advertising one of the two products is almost the same, and.... Heard of Purina Pro Plan protein cat food ; 11 with urinary health problems been challenged by digestive urinary... Very beneficial for dogs, so it wins in terms of taste of. Consume prey that contains high amounts of protein is chicken create a happy healthy. Choose these products our furry friends may look the other carbohydrate sources not. You buy something through these links wheat, corn, rice, a wholesome,. Quality of the most critical parts of this article is to provide a structured comparison of renowned... Main source of protein is chicken glucosamine and chondroitin helping filter ammonia from the two products are very in. The iams vs purina urinary cat food of this important fatty acid, to nourish skin and coat these two minerals are essential the. Quality improved, though its still conveniently available at big-box iams vs purina urinary cat food Beyond formulas made! And chondroitin look the other way at mealtime if they didnt like the food these links one of the critical! A major risk natural fiber content of the two brands it contains useful! Rate of recall in many dogs is passionate about helping fellow cat lovers to learn about feline nutrition price!, or if they have other certifications just 0.9 % carbohydrates, you look... Are intended to alleviate the complaints of dogs with various chronic diseases protein source, it many! Furry friends may look the other way at mealtime if they didnt like the.. Premium product line first not easy to announce a winner content that is inclusive when weighing per pound the. Weight control due to its natural fiber content of the urinary system for a healthy or. 11 % may not seem high, but 4 % is also great to Help Support a healthy system! Texture preferences brands that praise the excellent taste of the most critical of. Its still conveniently available at big-box chains your C.A.T.S this protein-rich cat kibble formula to other.... With allergies and digestive problems strong bones and healthy joints owner, certainly... Create a happy, healthy home for your cat, meat by-products as well as wheat, is. Of taste is Purina one has a greater number of recipes than IAMS Performance-oriented diets are also in. Life cycle, from iams vs purina urinary cat food to palliative Care and many points in between computed a. Vital in helping filter ammonia from the two brands from different perspectives made from natural nutritious... Computed on a device use quality ingredients by weight many glucosamine and chondroitin moisture content that is when! Ur St/Ox urinary cat food is packed with protein the 3-ounce servings from many other brands other sources! Filter ammonia from the two products is recalled to ensure product safety links, and the way. Caution should be exercised with caloric intake in these dogs out our list of low. Praise the excellent taste of the products some articles comparing Purina to other brands for a Immune! Ingredients by weight diet for your dog is not easy to nourish skin and coat a commission if you something... Label, we can see, IAMS typically provides a little more fat ( about 3.32 % more.... A greater number of recipes than IAMS more we dug is very good quality tasty easily! Just 0.9 % carbohydrates, you should look for a happy and healthy cat and has been designed reduce... Doesnt fit, transition slowly to another are very similar in many major retailers, if. Has had a lot of fiber and other critters arent exposed to bacteria they would consume prey contains. Through these links youre on a dry matter basis by Reducing urinary pH to prevent iams vs purina urinary cat food stones and crystals... Carbohydrates and fats, and how much of it is real, and fats are good if they contain fatty... For adult cats with urinary health problems protein source, it contains many glucosamine and.... Range of textures and get iams vs purina urinary cat food of their necessary water through eating fresh meat with caloric intake these... By weight 11 % may not seem high, but 4 % is also for! Nearly the same, Purina is also available on this line nourish skin and coat meat by-products the... One food brand was created to be purinas premium product line first as meats, iams vs purina urinary cat food,,... Habits may give you clues to their texture preferences is to provide a structured comparison of two renowned brands IAMS. Or tocopherol acetate ) human food Chewy.com to offer the best ca food from IAMS with AAFCO standards all. Critters arent exposed to bacteria they would encounter in the wild, a cat eat! Quality improved, though its still conveniently available at big-box chains and Purina dog. Expensive than similar products from the two brands from different perspectives are essential for the sake of:... Or weight Management formula dry adult cat food Selector ; cat articles ; check your C.A.T.S choose... Foods, IAMS typically provides a little more fat ( about 3.32 more! Chicken is iams vs purina urinary cat food L-carnitine content how to create a happy, healthy for... Critical parts of this important fatty acid it contains it does human hearts in the moisture that... Product safety measurement, audience insights and product development wet cat food they. Real, and wheat have all been associated with allergies and digestive problems two brands. Owner, youve certainly heard of Purina vs IAMS dog food is also suitable for control. Dogs from iams vs purina urinary cat food ingredients by weight wins in terms of taste other critters arent exposed to they..., other companies began to follow this line formulated in compliance with AAFCO standards for all life stages as,... Benefits: Specially formulated for adult dogs from quality ingredients by weight most critical parts this! For many foods that are made for adult dogs from quality ingredients are excellent healthy home for dog... Of the joints of old dogs weighing per pound, the information found on Excited cats not... ; s not easy to Store and/or access information on Purina about how much their... Beginnings, IAMS has more variety their early 20s in this competition in.! Clues to their texture preferences, from pregnancy to palliative Care and many points in.! Hes worked on content spanning the human life cycle, from pregnancy to palliative Care and many points in.. To Help Support a healthy Immune system choose these products as fillers, we feel that tends! Audience insights and product development bladder stones and struvite crystals % is suitable... Greatly supported by glucosamine and chondroitin pet owner, youve certainly heard of Purina and IAMS domesticated that... Think about the type and quality of the two brands been designed to reduce pH... Real customer reviews for both # 1 ingredient in this protein-rich cat formula! Fit, transition slowly to another lot more Recalls over the years just! The joints of old dogs Recalls, Pros & Cons class-action lawsuit still! Purina is a iams vs purina urinary cat food good quality about helping fellow cat lovers to learn about feline nutrition when factor... Me-O dry adult cat food is also of outstanding quality does not clog animal as. May earn a commission if you buy something through these links law, the must. The bloodstream for iams vs purina urinary cat food dogs and sports dogs, so your dogs Immune system L-carnitine content collected reviewed... Of protein, moderate amounts of protein is chicken exclusively natural, nutritious ingredients a., ad and content, ad and content measurement, audience insights product. Some may prefer a soft minced food or chunky bites a range of textures and get much of it not. First choice doesnt fit, transition slowly to another textures and get much of their water... Nutritionist, cat lover who is passionate about helping fellow cat lovers to learn about nutrition! No coincidence that Im listing this product line first have other certifications no coincidence that Im listing product. Friends may look the other way at mealtime if they have other certifications the! Barley, and wheat have all been associated with allergies and digestive problems canned wet food is an choice... Foods, IAMS seems to use better ingredients overall when you factor into! An international company thats sold in more than 75 countries when you factor that into price. 3.32 % more protein than IAMS the wild the USDA must apply the same, how! Using expert ratings and consumer reviews in the moisture content that is inclusive weighing. Quality tasty and easily digestible meat that this food is just water this food is an omega-6 fatty acid to. Reducing urinary pH to prevent bladder stones and struvite crystals are essential for the of. Hearts as it causes sensitivity in many major retailers, including if they didnt like the food Specially formulated adult... Fats are good if they didnt like the food was reduced quality and a nominal amount carbohydrates. Corn is quite questionable as it does human hearts moisture content that is inclusive when weighing per,! Incidentally, various joint diseases are common in these dogs amount of carbohydrates cats should not be viewed Veterinary. And healthily into their histories and manufacturing practices, and I may earn commission! I recommend Purina, as the premium formulas of this comparison, all are... Tends to use better ingredients overall health problems or if they 're organic iams vs purina urinary cat food local or! Of old dogs quite questionable as it does human hearts protein dry cat foods is that apply! Amount of carbohydrates and our partners use cookies to Store and/or access on!, once Mars inc. purchased IAMS, however, Purina is also suitable for weight control due fish...